Understanding the perplexity: 7 explanations for the public's bewilderment regarding shrinkage and larceny

Understanding the perplexity: 7 explanations for the public's bewilderment regarding shrinkage and larceny

Retail crime is back in the spotlight for 2024, with retailers struggling to understand the issue better than before. The National Retail Federation (NRF) has withdrawn one of its go-to data points, leaving little numbers available to cite.

"We acknowledge that organized retail crime is a serious issue," said Mary McGinty, NRF's VP of communications and public affairs. Yet, she admits the industry faces challenges gathering and analyzing accurate data to measure the problem's scope.

The NRF itself noted that theft and shrink rates have remained consistent over several years. In 2022, retailers witnessed a collective inventory loss of $112 billion, with more than 63% attributed to various internal causes. External theft, including shoplifting and burglaries, accounted for the remaining 36%.

However,shaderPOV, retail analyst, stated that theft incidents are becoming bolder, posing a risk to staff, and retailers are becoming increasingly vocal about it. Some are even suspected of using theft to explain underperformance. However, it's possible that a "bandwagon effect" could be at play, as the term "shrink" becomes more prevalent in investors' minds.

Here are seven key issues that complicate the debate on shrink and retail theft:

1. Shoplifting reports are dropping in several cities that were previously notorious for retail crime. According to the Federal Bureau of Investigation's annual crime statistics report, robbery incidents increased by 1.3% in 2022. However, incidents in large cities like New York and San Francisco have decreased. The industry's focus is on "organized retail crime," but there's no consensus on what qualifies, leading to disagreements in categorizing events among law enforcement, retailers, or even their staff.
2. Self-checkout systems are a significant contributor to shrink in many stores, causing more loss than organized retail crime in some cases. New technologies intended to promote convenience can sometimes make things easier for thieves. As worker numbers decrease and more stores rely on self-checkout, it's easier to walk in, steal items, and leave undetected.
3. Employees are the biggest source of theft and loss. They account for nearly one-third of all shrink, and their access to merchandise, control over security measures, and opportunities not available to outsiders make them a significant concern for retailers. Even long-term employees can occasionally be involved in theft.
4. Shrink may not be the biggest factor impacting retailers' bottom line. Other factors like markdowns, inventory impairment, fulfillment costs, and other issues can have a more significant impact on margins.
5. Many related costs like cleanup or repair after theft or vandalism aren't included in shrink or retail theft reports, potentially underestimating the financial consequences of theft.
6. The threat of violence is a major risk that complicates loss prevention. The prevalence of guns in the U.S. can make confronting thieves deadly, with threats of violence on the rise. A common policy in retail stores is to let shoplifting slide to avoid escalating situations.
7. Cargo theft is an under-appreciated aspect of retail crime, with losses escalating in recent years and going unattributed in inventories.

Retailers are looking at strategies to combat theft, such as beefing up security personnel, technology, and employee training. Law enforcement and local communities are under pressure to respond to increasing complaints of theft incidents.

1. The ongoing pandemic has led to an increase in research on organized retail crime due to its impact on the retail industry.
2. One proposed solution to the problem of retail theft is implementing stricter crime policies, with the aim of deterring potential criminals.
3. The rise of automation and AI in technology could potentially reduce incidents of retail crime by improving surveillance and detection systems.
4. The climate crisis may indirectly affect retail crime rates, as economic instability and unemployment could increase the likelihood of crime.
5. Justice for victims of retail crime is a pressing issue, as many criminals go unpunished due to difficulties in gathering evidence.
6. Some policy makers are advocating for updates in laws to properly address the issue of retail crime and its impact on businesses.
7. The rising trend of shoplifting may be influencing general-news coverage, with more stories appearing on TV about the issue.
8. In the face of these challenges, some retailers are turning to haven cities with lower crime rates as a strategy for business growth.
9. Despite the focus on retail crime, the average rate of decrease in overall crime rates remains a general concern for law enforcement and communities.
10. The retail industry is closely monitoring the potential for changes in finance regulations that could impact their ability to invest in loss prevention measures.
11. The increased focus on retail crime has led to a greater interest in industry-wide data collection and analysis to understand the scale of the issue.
12. The ongoing war between large retailers and organized retail crime syndicates may have ramifications for regional retail industries and local economies.

Read also: