The Digital Euro: A Modernized, Yet Incomplete Replacement for Physical Cash
Regnology, a German Regtech company, is set to take over Wolters Kluwer's Financial Regulatory Reporting (FRR) unit.
The European Central Bank (ECB) is embarking on a project to digitize the Euro, known as the Digital Euro. While it aims to provide a more convenient and integrated digital payment option, the Digital Euro falls short in several key aspects that physical cash continues to excel in.
Comparing Function and Quality
| Aspect | Physical Cash | Digital Euro | |-----------------------------|-------------------------------------------|-----------------------------------------------------| | Medium of exchange | Universal, immediate, and accepted everywhere offline and online | Instant and secure digital payments across eurozone, both online and offline (with network limitations) | | Privacy | Complete anonymity in transactions | Offline payments have privacy preserved only between payer and payee; not necessarily fully anonymous or free from trace in all scenarios | | Offline use | Fully functional offline without any connection | Designed with offline capability but cannot fully replicate cash’s universal offline usability | | Trust model | Trustless, no reliance on intermediaries | Requires digital wallets managed by banks or intermediaries, involving some trust in institutions | | Resilience | Works without infrastructure dependency (e.g., power, internet) | Dependent on digital infrastructure, though efforts made to ensure some offline usability | | Issuance and value guarantee | Physical currency guaranteed by central bank | Digital euro is central bank money with full value parity and elastic supply unlike stablecoins |
Limitations Preventing Full Replacement of Physical Cash
- Incomplete Offline Functionality: Physical cash works anywhere without power or internet; the Digital Euro’s offline features are designed but cannot fully replicate cash’s universal offline usability.
- Privacy and Anonymity Constraints: Although the Digital Euro aims to offer a "cash-like" privacy level, it does not guarantee the anonymity and untraceability of physical cash, especially in digital record-keeping and supervisory contexts.
- Dependence on Trust and Intermediaries: Unlike cash, which does not require intermediaries, the Digital Euro requires digital wallets linked to banks or postal services, thus involving intermediaries and some level of trust.
- Technical Infrastructure Dependency: The digital format requires reliable digital infrastructure and device access, while cash functions independently of such systems.
- Limits on Holding Amounts and Usage: Regulatory frameworks may impose limits on how much digital euro can be held or transacted to manage risks, which physical cash does not have.
In summary, the Digital Euro complements but does not fully substitute physical cash because it cannot yet match cash's offline universality, absolute privacy, and trust independence. It is designed to modernize and supplement the monetary system rather than completely replace physical currency.
The Digital Euro will be issued by the ECB in limited quantities, preserving scarcity, but its integration into wallets comes with holding caps, making it less flexible than banknotes. Cash's unique combination of privacy, simplicity, and resilience is hard to replicate and still deeply needed.
When tested against cash, the Digital Euro fares better in portability, divisibility, and digital performance; equal in scarcity, legal tender status, and unit of account; and worse in most other categories, especially anonymity, fungibility, recognizability, offline usability, and perceived reliability. The offline functionality of Digital Euro prototypes is untested at scale and may be subject to design trade-offs.
Cash is immune to network failures, battery issues, and software bugs, and its durability and reliability exceed that of a cloud-based CBDC. The Digital Euro will not be something you "see" in a wallet, and trust will need to be built through interfaces, branding, and user experience. The Digital Euro is intended to be the digital equivalent of the Euro banknote, trusted, stable, and accessible to everyone across the Eurozone.
- Despite the ambition to digitize the Euro, the Digital Euro faces limitations in matching the offline universality of physical cash.
- The privacy and anonymity level offered by the Digital Euro is not as comprehensive as that of physical cash, especially in regards to digital record-keeping and supervisory contexts.
- Unlike cash, the Digital Euro requires the use of digital wallets linked to banks or intermediaries, adding a level of dependence on these institutions.
- The Digital Euro's functioning relies on digital infrastructure and device access, which is unlike the independence of cash.
%20unit.){kind=link}