Montreal enacts novel guidelines for short-term rentals

Montreal enacts novel guidelines for short-term rentals

Montreal Cracks Down on Short-Term Rentals: A Game Changer for Housing and Tourism

Montreal has taken a decisive step to tackle the housing crisis and combat unauthorized real estate listings with a nine-month ban on certain short-term rentals. From March, only primary residences can be rented for up to 31 days during the peak tourist season, from June 10 to September 10, providing a significant blow to the long-standing battle against illegal short-term rental listings.

Homeowners must obtain a $300 permit from the city and adhere to the previous registration requirements set by the province. Permanent Airbnb rentals managed by commercial enterprises are still allowed in specific areas of the city but are limited to a few streets and sectors.

In the past, some property owners had managed to avoid fines by declaring their rental property as their primary residence. However, with the new regulations, the burden of proof has shifted onto the owners of the listings, making it easier for inspectors to impose fines. As Despina Sourias, the city councilor responsible for housing, explains, "Without a permit, you get a ticket, and if you do it outside the allowed hours, you get a ticket."

The new regulations mark an intensification in a province-wide crackdown that was initiated following a tragic fire in an old Montreal building in March 2023, where seven people died, six of whom were staying in Airbnb rentals not allowed in that part of the city. After the fire, the provincial government introduced a new law requiring platforms like Airbnb to only display listings with a tourist permit number and an expiration date. The city also hired a team of inspectors to enforce the rules.

Some argue that the new rules could hurt Montreal's economy and do little to improve housing affordability. Alex Howell, Airbnb's head of public policy in Canada, calls the new rule change "extreme and short-sighted." However, David Wachsmuth, Canada Research Chair in Urban Governance at McGill University, believes Montreal could succeed in combating illegal rentals where others have failed. He points out that enforcing these rules will now be easier as anyone operating an Airbnb outside of designated full-time rental zones can automatically be fined during the off-peak summer season.

Critics may raise concerns about the economic fallout due to these regulations, but increased long-term rentals and reduced competition for housing could potentially stabilize or even reduce rental prices for locals, improving housing affordability. As Wachsmuth asserts, research "unequivocally shows" that communities that have implemented rules on short-term rentals see their rents increase more slowly than those that do not. With the new regulations coming into effect this summer, only time will tell if Montreal can successfully balance its efforts to address the housing crisis while minimizing negative economic impacts.

Unraveling the Impact

As Montreal takes a hard line on short-term rentals, housing affordability and the city's economy stand at a crossroads. By limiting short-term rentals and fostering long-term leases, Montreal aims to reduce competition in the housing market, potentially lowering rental prices for locals. On the other hand, the restriction of short-term rentals may have negative economic implications, with reduced tourism, job losses among hosts and property managers, and potential financial strain for businesses that thrive on the short-term rental market. Finding the right equilibrium between these concerns will be essential for Montreal as it navigates its new regulatory landscape.

Affordable Housing

• Consolidation of Long-Term Rentals: By reducing the number of short-term rentals on the market, more long-term housing could become available for residents, potentially easing the strain on the city's housing market and improving affordability[1][5].
• Reduced Rental Competition: With fewer short-term rentals, there will be less competition for housing stock, potentially stabilizing or reducing rental prices for locals[1][5].

Economic Impact

• Tourism Slump: As the number of short-term rentals drops, tourism could suffer, particularly outside the peak season, causing a ripple effect through industries such as restaurants, shops, and tourist services[2][3].
• Job Losses: Reductions in short-term rentals could lead to job losses for hosts and property managers who rely on these rentals for their primary income[3].
• Stagnating Revenue: Smaller short-term rental numbers are likely to result in less income for hosts and reduced revenue for the city overall[2][3].

1. The new regulations in Montreal, focusing on short-term rentals, aim to foster long-term leases, which could potentially lower rental prices for locals and ease the strain on the city's housing market.
2. One possible negative economic implication of these regulations is a slump in tourism, particularly outside the peak season, causing a ripple effect through industries such as restaurants, shops, and tourist services.
3. Reductions in short-term rentals could lead to job losses for hosts and property managers who rely on these rentals for their primary income.
4. Finding the right balance between affordable housing and maintaining a healthy economy will be crucial for Montreal, as the new regulatory landscape navigates its impact on policy and legislation in the real-estate sector, finance, politics, and general news.

Read also: