Asians Seize the Lead: Struggling German Car Makers Lose Ground to Asian Competitors
German automakers trail competitors in innovation and efficiency advancements
Get the latest updates on this topic: Facebook | Twitter | WhatsApp | Email | Print | Copy Link
The German car industry is facing a tough battle as Asian manufacturers ramp up their game. According to a recent analysis by EY, the sales and profits of Germany's leading automakers are seeing a downward trend while Asian competitors, particularly those from China, are making impressive strides.
A dismal quarter for German automakers saw their combined sales decline by 2.3%. Only Volkswagen managed to eke out a slight increase, while heavy hitters like BMW and Mercedes-Benz suffered significant drops. Profit took an even bigger hit, falling by about a third for all three combined. US manufacturers experienced a similar fate, with a 2.9% sales drop and almost a third in profit.
On the other hand, business was thriving in Asia, with Chinese manufacturers leading the charge. They reported a 14.7% increase in sales and a staggering 66% surge in profits. BYD and Volvo's parent company Geely were at the forefront. Japanese and South Korean manufacturers also outperformed their European and American counterparts. An indication of the dominance of Asian manufacturers in the global auto industry is the fact that five of the six most profitable carmakers in the world are from Asia, with only BMW breaking the Asian dominance with a 9.3% profit margin.
"A Ticking Time Bomb"
The situation doesn't seem to be improving, warns EY market observer Constantin Gall. Instead, the crisis is expected to worsen throughout the year. "The automotive industry is currently being challenged on multiple fronts, with some established manufacturers' entire business models at risk," said Gall. "If profits continue to erode, some manufacturers may face existential questions, as competition in the automotive industry is intensifying."
Economy "A Looming Catastrophe" The struggle faced by established automakers, led by the Germans, is due to a combination of factors like lackluster economic growth, high costs, and slow adoption of electric vehicles. The Chinese market, once a stronghold for Western manufacturers, is also drying up as domestic players gain prominence. To make matters worse, the 25% tariffs imposed by US President Trump on auto imports since April are causing further damage to the industry.
The threatened high tariffs could result in losses totaling billions of dollars, not only for European but also US manufacturers. The gap between Chinese manufacturers, who are not present in the US, and their competitors continues to widen.
Economy Figures Offer a Distorted Picture Electric vehicles continue to be a rare sight among private consumers, with only a handful adopting the technology. Several manufacturers and suppliers have already announced cost-cutting programs and job cuts in recent months. While cost-cutting may help alleviate the immediate pain, experts argue that Western automakers must undergo a complete transformation, including comprehensive digitalization, faster vehicle development, and quicker decision-making.
Manufacturers can learn valuable lessons from the up-and-coming challengers from the East. "The success of Chinese providers highlights that it's not just about investing a lot of money," says Gall. "Speed, flexibility, and a clear focus on investments are equally important."
In a minor triumph for VW, the company managed to match Toyota in terms of revenue, albeit lagging behind in sales and operating profit in the first quarter. While VW sold more cars than Toyota in 2019, it lost the title of the world's largest automaker to the Japanese in the subsequent period.
Sources: ntv.de, rog/dpa
- Automakers
- German Automakers
- Volkswagen
- BMW
- Mercedes-Benz Group AG
- Chinese Automakers
Insights from Enrichment Data:
- Asian automakers, particularly those from China, are outperforming German automakers due to their strong domestic market growth, competitive pricing, and aggressive expansion into new markets.
- German automakers face challenges in maintaining their market share and are responding with strategies focused on electrification and strategic partnerships.
- Key factors contributing to the success of Chinese automakers include aggressive expansion into new markets, competitive pricing, and a diverse and innovative product lineup.
- Declining sales and profits, slow adoption of electric vehicles, and competition from Asian brands are some of the challenges faced by German automakers.
- To stay competitive, Western automakers need to reinforce their focus on electrification, strategic partnerships, and quicker decision-making, in addition to comprehensive digitalization and faster vehicle development.
The community policy for the German automakers needs to address the challenges posed by Asian competitors, specifically Chinese manufacturers, as they continue to outperform German automakers, owing to strong domestic market growth, competitive pricing, and aggressive expansion into new markets. To compete effectively, vocational training programs could be implemented to improve speed, flexibility, and decision-making within the organizations. Finance initiatives could also be integrated into the community policy, focusing on cost-cutting, electrification, strategic partnerships, and comprehensive digitalization to drive growth and profits, thereby safeguarding the future of the German automakers.
