Cranking Up Germany's Economy: IW Director Huether Pushes for Fewer Holidays, More Productivity
Boosting Economic Output Suggested by IW Director Hüther through Reducing Public Holidays
Share on FB Tweet this Share on Whatsapp Email this Print this Copy Link
In a bold move, Michael Huether, the director of the Institute of the German Economy (IW Cologne), has proposed fewer public holidays in Germany, claiming it could be a quick and effective method to amp up economic performance. Speaking to the Funke media group, he asserted, "Scrapping a holiday would turbocharge our economy!" According to IW calculations, an extra day of work could increase Germany's GDP by up to €8.6 billion.
Huether's comments follow the Association of Bavarian Businesses' call this week to eliminate a religious holiday. Huether, however, has previously advocated for the abolition of the Buß- and Bettag as a public holiday in 1995, stating, "If you want it, more work is definitely possible!"
Marcel Fratzscher, CEO of the German Institute for Economic Research (DIW Berlin), offers a different perspective. Fratzscher argues that the labor shortage in Germany won't be resolved by scrapping holidays, stating, "The key lies in eliminating barriers to employment for women, refugees, and foreigners." He emphasized the importance of significant immigration and the removal of these barriers to alleviate the labor shortage.
A deeper look reveals the following arguments for and against reducing public holidays in Germany:
Arguments for fewer public holidays:- Maximizing productivity: Reducing public holidays means more workdays, potentially improving overall economic output and productivity. This is particularly significant for Germany, facing economic challenges like contraction, recession, and layoffs in key industries.- Supporting economic growth: The German government is focusing on stimulating growth and modernizing infrastructure. Limiting holidays could be seen as a supportive measure to bolster these initiatives by maximizing labor input.- Maintaining competitiveness: Germany, being Europe's largest economy, heavily depends on exports, particularly to markets like China and the US. Limiting holidays could help maintain competitiveness by aligning work hours with global market demands.
Arguments against fewer public holidays:- Employee well-being: Public holidays offer rest and recreation, linking to better work-life balance, reduced stress, and increased job satisfaction. Healthier, happier employees are often more productive and motivated.- Indirect economic benefits: Public holidays foster consumer spending and tourism, positively impacting the economy. They also strengthen social cohesion, allowing people to celebrate cultural traditions and spend time with loved ones.- Flexible leave management: Germany provides schemes like annual leave purchase, giving employees flexibility without needing to change public holidays.- Potential negative impact on morale: Limiting public holidays could negatively affect employee morale and work culture, possibly offsetting any gains in productivity by lowering motivation and increasing burnout.
In essence, the debate centers around the potential short-term economic gains of fewer holidays versus long-term social and productivity benefits tied to public holidays. Flexible schemes like leave buying/selling offer alternatives without drastically altering public holiday laws. Employers and policymakers must weigh the pros and cons to find a balanced approach that benefits both the economy and workers.
- The employment policy should consider the potential impact of reducing public holidays on employee well-being, as time off fosters better work-life balance, reduced stress, and increased job satisfaction, which in turn translates to increased productivity.
- In light of the Association of Bavarian Businesses' call for eliminating a religious holiday and Michael Huether's advocacy for fewer public holidays, it is crucial for the finance ministry to formulate a comprehensive employment policy that balances economic growth with employee well-being, ensuring that the labor shortage can be addressed through measures like eliminating barriers to employment for women, refugees, and foreigners, rather than just cutting holidays.
